Perhaps not a bug?

[Ryme]

Not really a bug. The special option is rolled each time, and won't remember that through logout. Sorry you missed it, but that "feature" is likely to stay the way it is.

[zillow]

So if someone had time to waste they could wait until after SPOILER time, get the non-combat, and log in and out until they get the 4th option?

[Ryme]

So if someone had time to waste they could wait until after SPOILER time, get the non-combat, and log in and out until they get the 4th option?

Uh, not anymore. Any "return to where you were after a logout" option will track and prevent the special option from showing up.